[vrwm]

It would be an awesome addition to the forum. I was looking for some old reviews Nica had and still can't find them. It would be a great place to direct people who have questions about certain products, and an easy way to find reviews for reference.

[Nica]

hmmmm...not a bad idea, let me see what I can do

[LanceM]

A product review would be great. I saw it on detail U and liked it.

[Tonya]

Great idea!

[distrbd]

It's a good Idea,what I would like to see is to review a product but also a direct one to one comparison of the reviewed item to a popular product of the same category.
A good example would be lets say a review of CG EZ cream and then a comparison to Meg.#7 ,or DG Aquawax and Pinnacle soveran spray wax(synthetic vs carnauba) , CG Jetseal109 and DG 105 .

[vrwm]

Originally Posted by distrbd

It's a good Idea,what I would like to see is to review a product but also a direct one to one comparison of the reviewed item to a popular product of the same category.
A good example would be lets say a review of CG EZ cream and then a comparison to Meg.#7 ,or DG Aquawax and Pinnacle soveran spray wax(synthetic vs carnauba) , CG Jetseal109 and DG 105 .

Thats a good one,too. It could be like a product review section, and like a versus section. It could be great because I got a lot of LSPs coming to compare.

[Nica]

Originally Posted by distrbd

It's a good Idea,what I would like to see is to review a product but also a direct one to one comparison of the reviewed item to a popular product of the same category.
A good example would be lets say a review of CG EZ cream and then a comparison to Meg.#7 ,or DG Aquawax and Pinnacle soveran spray wax(synthetic vs carnauba) , CG Jetseal109 and DG 105 .

I think you guys are on to something here okay I'll put something together and you guys let me know what you think. I'll try to come up with a way of doing a review, kinda like a guideline, like pointers as to how to compare....I've seen such guidelines around the different forums and they sound good but at the same time I think it's important to keep it creative, I mean just becuase there is a guideline it dosent mean that you can't do it your way that's all.

But like I said I'll come up with something and you guys can make the final call, how's that sound?

[vrwm]

That sounds great Looking forward to it.

[Tonya]

Originally Posted by Nica

I think you guys are on to something here okay I'll put something together and you guys let me know what you think. I'll try to come up with a way of doing a review, kinda like a guideline, like pointers as to how to compare....I've seen such guidelines around the different forums and they sound good but at the same time I think it's important to keep it creative, I mean just becuase there is a guideline it dosent mean that you can't do it your way that's all.

But like I said I'll come up with something and you guys can make the final call, how's that sound?

Sounds great you are really on to something! I like the you stated it is just a guideline and it can be done in any format. Some new members might not be able to do a comparison if they have never used any other products or only used OTC products.

[Nica]

Originally Posted by Rocco

Sounds great you are really on to something! I like the you stated it is just a guideline and it can be done in any format. Some new members might not be able to do a comparison if they have never used any other products or only used OTC products.

yes I agree but to be honest creativity is something that we all have and should always be incuraged well at least I think so but that's just me